Author Login | Popular Articles | RSS Feeds | Sitemap

Home | Reference-and-education


Eyewitness Testimony: An Enduring Topic Of Psychological Enquiry

By: David Webb

The study of eyewitness testimony can be traced back over 100 years. This article outlines how it all began and examines the most commonly researched areas of investigation.

In 1896 Albert Von Schrenk-Notzing testified at the trial of a man accused of murdering three women. Drawing on research into memory and suggestibility he argued that pre-trial publicity meant that witnesses could not distinguish between what they actually saw and what had been reported in the press.

The formal study of eyewitness testimony is usually examined within a framework of cognitive processing, which put simply refers to the different ways in which we make sense of the world around us.

We do this by employing the mental skills at our disposal such as thinking, perception, memory, awareness, reasoning and judgment. Although cognitive processes can only be inferred and cannot be seen directly, they all have very important practical implications within a legal context.

Given that the way we think, perceive, reason and judge can be less than perfect it’s easy to understand why the factors influencing these processes are studied by psychologists'; not least because of the grave implications that this imperfection can have within the criminal justice system. As Huff and Rattner note:

the single most important factor contributing to wrongful conviction is eyewitness misidentification.

Stages of eyewitness memory:

Stage 1: Witnessing the incident.

When witnessing an incident, information about the event is entered into memory, however, research has shown that the accuracy of this initial information acquisition can be influenced by a number of factors.

Take the duration of the event being witnessed for instance. In a very simple experiment conducted by Clifford and Richards(1977), participants are instructed to approach a number of police officers and engage in conversation for either 15 or 30 seconds.

Thirty seconds after the conversation ends, the experimenter asks the police officer to recall details of the person they had just been speaking to using a 10-item checklist. The checklist contains items relating to the persons appearance such as hair colour, facial hair etc. The results of the study showed that in the longer 30 second condition, police were significantly more accurate in their recall.

Stage 2: Waiting period before giving evidence.

This stage is concerned with the period of retention between perception i.e., seeing an incident and the subsequent recollection of that incident. Unsurprisingly, research has consistently found that the longer the gap between witnessing an incident and recalling the incident, the less accurate the recollection of that incident becomes.

There have been numerous experiments, usually related to a staged event, that support this contention. Malpass and Devine (1981), for instance, compared the accuracy of witness identifications after 3 days (short retention period) and 5 months (long retention period). The study found no false identifications after 3 days but after 5 months, 35% of identifications were false.

Stage 3: Giving evidence.

The final stage in the eyewitness memory process relates to the ability of the witness to access and retrieve information from memory. In a legal context, the retrieval of information is usually elicited through a process of questioning and it is for this reason that a great deal of research has investigated the impact of types of questioning on eyewitness memory.

The most substantial body of research has concerned leading questions, which has consistently shown that even very subtle changes in the wording of a question can influence subsequent testimony.

One of the most notable researchers in this field is Elizabeth Loftus who has been investigating eyewitness testimony for over thirty years. In one of her classic studies, participants witnessed a film of a car accident and were asked to estimate the speed of the cars involved. One group of witnesses were asked to estimate the speed of the cars when they contacted each other. A second group of witnesses were asked to estimate the speed of the cars when they smashed each other.

On average the first 'contacted' group gave an estimate of 31.8 miles per hour. Whereas, the average speed in the 'second' smashed group was 40.8 miles per hour.

Experimental validity:

In any discussion of eyewitness memory, you'll see the terms, 'experiment', 'participants' and 'staged event' frequently used. This is because the majority of research into eyewitness memory has been conducted within psychology laboratories.

This raises the very important issue of whether it is possible to generalise the findings obtained under these artificial conditions to real life cases.

The simple, if unsatisfactory answer is that it is very difficult to say. Take for instance the work of Yuille and Cutshall, these researchers conducted a case study with witnesses to a real shooting incident, interviewing them just after the event and again 5 months later. They concluded that the performance and accuracy of the witnesses differed in several respects to what would be expected according to the experimental literature.

However, the strength of laboratory based research is that the experimenter is able to exercise a great deal of control over what happens. In the case study reported by Yuille and Cutshall, it was impossible to know the extent to which the witnesses had conferred and how much media coverage of the incident they had seen, and how much influence this had on their testimony.

If you'd like to find out more about eyewitness memory, you can do so by visiting www.all-about-forensic-psychology.com

Article Source: http://www.articlesnatch.com

About the Author:
Since 2000, David Webb has been involved in collaborative research with teams of forensic scientists in the UK, US and Canada. He has produced two websites based on his teaching and research experience. http://www.all-about-forensic-science.com and http://www.all-about-forensic-psychology.com

| Print | Ezine Ready | |

Recent Reference-and-Education Articles

  • Basic Principles of Solar Power By: Anna Williams - This article will describe how solar power is created and go over some of its basic principles. Solar energy is created by light and heat which is emitted by the sun, in the form of electromagnetic radiation.
  • Lcf Clubs: The Fun Way To Learn Spanish And French By: John Ellis - The importance of foreign languages like French and Spanish is growing. Many parents and guardians are enrolling their children in after school clubs that provide lessons in foreign languages. One of the most popular after school clubs in the UK is LCF clubs.
  • Spanish Lessons Through The Online Medium By: John Ellis - Nowadays, foreign languages are an important part of the school curriculum. When schools don’t include languages in their curriculum, the parents send their children to after school classes that offer opportunities to learn a new language.
  • Temporary Work Applications: When is Immigrating Allowed By: Roberto Bell - Individuals who are Canadian or Mexican citizens are eligible to apply for a temporary employment visa to work in the U.S. under the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA).
  • Take your Career to New Heights: Life Experience Degree Programs By: Roberto Bell - If getting a college degree based on credit awarded by life experience seems a little far-fetched, think again. People actually can – and do – receive college degrees at almost every level based on work experience.
  • Medical Assistant Salary Average Pay For CMAs By: Louis Zhang - According to the American Association of Medical Assistants (AAMA) a medical assistant salary is one of those with the best future prospects as the need for doctor's assistants is set to rise as the population gets older.
  • Online Tutors: Tuition Help For Students By: Alicia Beg - Advances in data and technology have intensely revolutionized every sphere of novel life and communication is no immunity. The belief of online lessons owes greatly to the prompt development in the theme of communication. Virtual lessons are a relatively new belief in reserve lessons.
  • How to succeed with distance learning By: N33 Johnson33 - How to succeed with distance learning A million miles from cold, draughty classrooms - imagine studying in a warm cosy place, your favourite music playing in the background and as many hot drinks as you like.
  • A new generation of vocational training By: N22 Johnson22 - A new generation of vocational training Before the advent of computer technology, with large numbers of unskilled labourers needed to work in manufacturing and service industries, it wasn’t considered necessary or advisable to provide much by way of vocational training for adults.
  • Online Tutoring – A Real Boon when Class Gets Tough By: Crg White - The classroom is the foundation of public education systems worldwide. Unfortunately, some students find classroom learning to be a constant struggle. They work their hardest but can’t seem to grasp certain concepts. With the pressure to perform well, these students face added stress from falling grades.

Search Ebay

Still can't find what you are looking for? Search for it!


Submit Your link to the Open Link Directory Project

Copyright 2005-2008 MJE Sales, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Proud member of the ArticleCkr Search Network Search Network!
ArticleSnatch.com is free for both publishers and authors to use and is supported entirely from advertising revenue.
Use of our service is protected by our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.