Beware: Groupthink!

On January 28, 1986, the space shuttle Challenger blasted off from the Kennedy Space Centre in Florida. Seventy-three seconds later, millions of people watched as the rocket disintegrated in a fiery explosion, and the capsule plunged into the Atlantic Ocean. The death of all seven crew members, and particularly teacher Christa McAuliffe, shocked the world. As we learned in the months that followed, the tragedy could and should have been avoided. The root cause of the disaster was something known as Groupthink.

Groupthink did not exist before 1972! Irving Janis, a social psychologist focusing on the political arena, was puzzled by the inability of otherwise very clever and intelligent people to make sound decisions, and in fact their tendency to make ones that sometimes created disastrous results. His answer was a condition he termed Groupthink.

What is Groupthink and how to spot it

Groupthink is a mode of thinking that people engage in when they are deeply involved in a cohesive, task-centred group, when their need for unanimity supersedes the need to make a decision based on rational information. Groupthink can lead to bad judgments and decisions being made, and can also cause a group of decision makers to rationalise a poor decision after the fact. It's a simple and totally inadequate way to deal with difficult issues.

While discord and conflict among individuals is one major pitfall among decision-makers, Groupthink is equally dangerous. Group cohesiveness is a good quality and something all groups need to strive for, but Groupthink takes this cohesiveness to the extreme. One Shine Consulting client recently said to me "It's terrifying to see how people all line up behind the key influencers [in this team] without ever questioning the decision, or the basis on which the decision is being put forward".

Groupthink happens frequently when a group is under pressure to make a decision. Ironically this happens in organisations at the most crucial time - often when strategic decisions need to be made to satisfy corporate leaders or shareholders. Hence the total incredulity often seen when strategy decisions are "communicated" down the line to those not on the decision-making body but closer to the facts!

How to avoid Groupthink

If any of the above situations strikes a chord with you in your organisation, there are a number of actions you can take to avoid Groupthink:

1. Notice when Groupthink is happening and point it out to the group - both its causes and consequences

2. If you're going against the group it helps to make this explicit by saying something like, "this may annoy some of you but.../I know this is going against the way we are thinking at the moment but..". You are much more likely to be heard sympathetically rather than ganged up on by the group trying to maintain its path

3. Ahead of time, appoint one of the group members to play "devil's advocate" and to challenge the group, looking for flaws in logic, false inferences and overlooked information

4. Test your thinking. Get out of your cocoon and ask questions of those who will be impacted by the group's decisions. Pick up the phone, call a customer, or walk around and get a reality check! Encouraging feedback on what worked and what didn't about previous decisions will also help keep your feet on the ground. Ask group members to get feedback from their own constituents before a final decision is made

5. Create one or more independent decision-making groups with different leaders to work on the same critical issue or policy, then bring the sub-groups together to hammer out differences of data, assumptions and solutions

6. Get the group to make a formal presentation (including their data, assumptions and conclusions) to its leader (and possibly to his/her manager too). Have the group evaluate the decision-making process as part of the presentation

7. The leader should avoid stating preferences and expectations at the outset. Doing so creates pressure for others to agree

8. As a leader, encourage dissent and alternative comments. Remind everyone that open and frank communication is essential to good decision making and a healthy culture

9. If the decision is particularly important, or you think your decision-making process needs a fresh pair of eyes, ask a facilitator a) to be a fly on the wall and give feedback to the group or b) to lead the group through the process

It was Mark Twain who humbly stated: "Between me and God we have all knowledge. God knows all there is to know, and I know the rest."

About the Author:
Shine Consulting specialise in individual, team and leadership development in organisations whose leaders want people to thrive and to produce results well beyond the predictable. Shine works with individuals, teams and leaders who are frustrated that they are not achieving the results they know they should be, to surface and resolve permanently the underlying issues and help them produce outstanding results.

Article Originally Published On: http://www.articlesnatch.com

Tags: thinking

, group

, decision

, management

, business

, cohesive

, organisation

, strategy

, leader

, result

Related....

Videos...

Recent Business Articles

Mining Machinery Relies On Technological Advance By: nicole | May 26th 2012 - Mining machinery relies on technological advance
The modern economic development is inseparable from science and technology. The development of mining machinery are closely related to the progress of modern science and technology and the overall industrial level, i ...

Website Placering Er Ikke Et Sikkert: Ligesom En Rang Tyveri By: heena | May 26th 2012 - Motoren anvende metoder til indeksering i de analyse websted med hver kategori crawler kun gennemg indhold, fordi p internettet hver resultatet er show for kun indhold website ranking brug for kun organisk resultat af web-resultat

S�'gemaskineoptimering

Advantages Of Energy-saving Re-creation Dryer By: nicole | May 26th 2012 - Advantages of Energy-saving Re-creation Dryer
Factors Restricting Domestic In modern society, environmental protection has been gradually incorporated into the cost of economic development, all countries are making efforts to achieve maximum economic efficiency und ...

Orange County Ca Real Estate Down Payment Options By: Jeremy G. Bruck | May 26th 2012 - If youve made it your goal to buy property in Orange County, you may feel that your efforts may be in vain, especially when you think about the amount of money youll need for a down payment. However, before you let that idea stop you from conducting a houses for Or ...

Real Estate in Orange County

Create Core Product Of Jaw Crusher Is Needed By: nicole | May 26th 2012 - Create Core Product of Jaw Crusher is needed
How to Create Core Product of Jaw Crusher

With the demand and construction in mining machinery transferring to China, China has become the manufacturing center of global construction machinery. And meanwhile ...

Your First Classic Car, What To Consider By: rajesh | May 26th 2012 - To many, there is nothing better than the charm of a classic car.When your looking to buy your first classic car there are a lot of things to look at to ensure you get what you are looking for.

john rosatti

Splash Sider Er En God Måde For Website Bes�'gende By: heena | May 26th 2012 - med dette kan vi f alle de oplysninger, der krves p den frste side af hjemmesiden uden megen rulle som splash sider, og det krver med indlsning af vores hjemmeside.

S�'gemaskineoptimering

Charming Hall Table & Other Oak Furniture By: Jon William | May 26th 2012 - Creating a homey yet elegant atmosphere involves planning carefully and choosing sturdy furnishings, like hallway oak furniture with an earthy vibe. Space planners who meld design, art & aesthetics and juxtapose old with new elements often favor such types of solid hard ...

oak bedroom furniture

Get Great Value For Money With Solid Oak Furniture By: Jon William | May 26th 2012 - The great thing about solid oak furniture is that it requires minimal upkeep and looks elegant, with its grain showing through. It is also less pricey than more exotic hardwood. Picture happy family dinners in a long oak table, which can be spruced up with pretty details ...

home office furniture uk

Factors To Consider For Finding The Best Obsolete Electronic Parts Supplier By: M.S. Hi-Tech | May 26th 2012 - We are well-aware of the fact that every electronic device is made of numerous individual electronic parts.

obsolete electronic parts

Comments

Still can't find what you are looking for? Search for it!

Site Navigation: